Beyond Wellbeing: Have We Lost Sight of thePurpose of Meditation?

A Vedic Meditation perspective on the ABC’s All in the Mind podcasts and Josh Pryor’s “Jarring Things” on the Yoga Australia website

Listening to the ABC’s All in the Mind two-part podcast series, When Meditation Goes Wrong, and reading Josh Pryor’s thoughtful response, Jarring Things, on the Yoga Australia website prompted me to reflect on how meditation is understood, taught and discussed today.

This is an important conversation. The experiences of distress described in the podcasts deserve to be heard and taken seriously. At the same time, we need a fuller understanding of meditation so that misunderstandings and generalisations do not unnecessarily deter people from a practice that can offer profound value.

I welcome Josh’s emphasis on traditional yogic knowledge, preparation and guidance. As a teacher of Shakti Mantra Vedic Meditation, drawing on the tradition of Maharishi Mahesh Yogi’s Transcendental Meditation, I would like to build on his argument by considering the deeper purpose of the practice.

Meditation is embedded within a wider philosophical and practical tradition concerned with consciousness and Self-knowledge. When it is presented primarily as a tool for stress relief and wellbeing, that context can disappear from view. I believe restoring it is essential to a more complete understanding of both the value of meditation and the questions raised by these podcasts.

More than a wellbeing technique

Meditation is frequently introduced as a way to reduce stress, improve sleep, manage emotions and support physiological and psychological wellbeing. These benefits matter. They may provide the initial motivation to learn, and research into them contributes to our understanding of the practice. Within the Vedic tradition in which I was trained, however, meditation belongs to a broader inquiry into human existence.

Who am I? Why am I here? What is the nature of consciousness? What gives life meaning and direction? Is there something about my existence that remains present amid the changing experiences of body and mind?

These questions concern the nature of the Self and our relationship with life. They take us beyond improving how we feel or how efficiently we function.

Yoga and Vedānta belong to the six āstika systems of Indian philosophy, which recognise the authority of the Vedas. Meditation is embedded within this wider tradition of philosophical inquiry and spiritual practice, concerned with consciousness, Self-knowledge and liberation. Within the Vedic tradition I teach, this inquiry points ultimately towards the recognition of oneness: a deeper understanding of the same underlying reality in ourselves and throughout life.

In Science of Being and Art of Living, Maharishi Mahesh Yogi presents meditation within this wider vision of human life. Central to his teaching is Being, or pure consciousness, understood within this tradition as unbounded and fundamental to life.

Maharishi taught that the mind can settle naturally through increasingly subtle levels of thought and transcend mental activity to experience pure awareness. The effortless mantra practice I teach follows this understanding.

The purpose of regular meditation extends beyond experiencing a restful interval during the day. Through the alternation of meditation and activity, this inner awareness is understood to become increasingly established in everyday life.

Meditation offers an experiential dimension to the search for Self-knowledge. Philosophical teaching provides a framework through which that experience may be understood. Together, practice and knowledge give meditation a depth that cannot be encompassed by its presentation as a wellbeing intervention alone.

What first brings us to meditation

I recently heard Swami Sarvapriyananda, a monk of the Ramakrishna Order and spiritual leader of the Vedanta Society of New York, quote Maharishi as saying:

“I give them what they want, so they will want what I give them.”

This saying captures something meaningful about how people may come to meditation. Someone begins because they want relief from stress, better sleep or greater ease in daily life. Through practice, they may discover an interest in something they had not initially sought: the nature of consciousness and their own existence.

There is nothing inadequate about beginning with practical needs. Relief from suffering matters. What first brings someone to meditation, however, need not define everything the practice has to offer.

My concern is that, when those initial benefits become the whole account of meditation, its deeper purpose and the knowledge accompanying it can disappear from view.

Established in Yoga, perform action

The meaning of transcendence also needs careful explanation.

The Bhagavad Gītā teaches:

Yogasthaḥ kuru karmāṇi

“Established in Yoga, perform action.”

— Bhagavad Gītā 2.48

In Maharishi’s interpretation, this teaching expresses the integration of Being and activity. Pure awareness is understood to become an enduring foundation alongside the changing experiences and responsibilities of life.

This gives transcendence a practical significance. We meditate, then bring that inner foundation into how we act, work and relate to others.

Transcendence should never become an excuse for spiritual bypassing, in which spiritual ideas or experiences are used to avoid emotional difficulties, responsibilities or the consequences of our actions. Losing touch with everyday reality or becoming unable to function should never be treated as evidence of spiritual achievement.

The teaching points towards fuller participation in life, with awareness supporting discernment, responsiveness and action.

Householder practice and the question of dosage

This relationship between meditation and activity is especially significant for the Householder. In the traditional Vedic framework, life is understood through four āśramas, or stages: student life, Householder life, gradual withdrawal from worldly responsibilities, and renunciation. The Sanskrit term gṛhastha, translated as “Householder”, refers to a person in the stage centred on family life, earning a living and contributing to society (Swami Paramarthananda, Introduction to Vedānta, 2008).

In the context of my teaching, I use Householder more broadly to describe those of us living in the modern world with family responsibilities, working lives and civic duties. We are not monks living in a monastery or ascetics devoting our lives exclusively to spiritual disciplines. We are Householders, and our meditation practice needs to support our participation in everyday life.

Maharishi brought Transcendental Meditation to people living ordinary lives, teaching a practice that could be integrated into their daily responsibilities. The approximately twenty-minute, twice-daily practice taught within my tradition reflects this orientation. The intention is to establish regular meditation alongside activity. Increasing the hours spent meditating should not automatically be regarded as progress.

I often use an analogy with pharmaceutical medicine. A medicine may offer considerable benefits, yet its suitability, dosage, frequency, contraindications and potential side effects all matter. We would never assume that taking eight times the recommended dose would produce eight times the benefit, or that the same prescription would suit everyone.

Meditation is not a pharmaceutical drug, and the analogy has its limitations. It nevertheless illustrates why duration, frequency and the circumstances of practice deserve consideration. The balance between meditation, rest and everyday activity is part of the methodology itself.

Are we comparing apples with apples?

The need to understand a particular practice also applies to how meditation is discussed publicly. Meditation encompasses many traditions and techniques, each with its own philosophical foundations, intentions and methods. Mindfulness-based practices represent particular approaches within this broader field and should not stand as a description of meditation as a whole.

Some techniques involve sustained concentration. Others cultivate observation of thoughts, emotions and bodily sensations. The Vedic mantra practice I teach is understood within its tradition as an effortless process that allows the mind to settle and transcend mental activity.

These methods are not interchangeable, nor should we assume that they produce identical experiences or effects. The ABC series included accounts of intensive Vipassanā and Zen retreats involving many hours of daily meditation. These are different undertakings from the brief, twice-daily practice taught within my tradition.

I have not trained in Zen or Vipassanā, so I cannot speak from experience about their instruction or the preparation provided to participants. Differences in method also do not, by themselves, establish differences in safety.

They do mean that we need to ask which technique was practised, at what intensity, by whom and under what conditions before drawing general conclusions. An adverse experience during an intensive retreat should not automatically be taken to describe every form of meditation. Equally, we should not assume that a traditional practice is entirely without risk, even when taught and practised correctly.

Preparation and the practitioner

Josh draws on the Gheraṇḍa Saṃhitā to discuss appropriate preparation and conditions for yogic practices, particularly prāṇāyāma. His argument reminds us that traditional teaching attends to the circumstances in which a practice is undertaken.

Vyāsa’s commentary on Patañjali’s Yoga Sūtras recognises different conditions of mind. For me, this reinforces the importance of finding the right practice for the right person. Not every meditation practice will be suitable for every person. In the Vedic meditation tradition I teach, we begin with an interview to understand the prospective student’s circumstances and assess whether the practice is suitable for them before proceeding with instruction.

This raises questions relevant to anyone considering a demanding meditation retreat. What previous experience does the person have? Do they understand the nature and intensity of the practice? Are their physical and psychological circumstances considered? What support is available if difficulties emerge?

These questions concern the responsibilities involved in offering a practice and preparing people to undertake it. They should never become a way of blaming someone who experiences harm.

Readiness requires attention to the individual as well as the technique. Informed participation also requires a realistic account of what the practice involves, including its potential difficulties.

A good meditation or a successful meditation?

During my teacher training in Shakti Mantra Vedic Meditation, my teacher introduced a distinction that has stayed with me. She spoke of a good meditation and a successful meditation.

A good meditation may feel peaceful, restful and pleasant. A successful meditation, in the language of that teaching, may include restlessness, thoughts, physical sensations or uncomfortable emotions.

Within our tradition, such experiences may be understood in terms of the release of accumulated stress and saṃskāras, the impressions and habitual patterns that condition our experiences.

This helped me understand why pleasantness alone is an inadequate measure of meditation. A session that feels busy or unsettled is not necessarily a failed practice.

This interpretation also requires care. Calling an experience “successful” must never become a reason to disregard distress or encourage someone to endure harm.

Traditional explanations cannot establish that a particular difficulty is beneficial stress release. Some adverse experiences extend beyond temporary discomfort and may require psychological, psychiatric or other medical support.

Meditation, including Transcendental Meditation, can be associated with difficulties even when someone has received proper instruction and practised conscientiously. Recognising this is part of responsible teaching.

The necessity of personal guidance

In Science of Being and Art of Living, Maharishi emphasises the necessity of personal instruction and guidance from a teacher. Within this teaching, learning meditation involves more than following written directions or receiving a mantra.

The teacher’s role continues beyond the initial instruction. Follow-up discussions, traditionally called checking, help practitioners establish the method correctly, clarify misunderstandings and understand their experiences.

Without guidance, someone may interpret a restless meditation as failure, try to force the mind into stillness or independently increase their practice in pursuit of a particular experience. The teacher can help address these misunderstandings and maintain an appropriate practice. This guidance also extends to more intensive practices such as rounding, which are undertaken under a trained teacher’s supervision within our tradition.

Books, apps, recordings and videos can introduce people to contemplative practices. They do not necessarily provide the personal instruction and ongoing relationship required within a particular teaching methodology.

In the tradition I teach, the teaching relationship is part of the methodology itself.

That relationship also requires teachers to recognise the limits of their competence. When difficulties are persistent, severe or interfere with everyday functioning, support beyond the meditation teacher’s role may be necessary. Personal guidance includes recognising when to refer someone for appropriate care.

Understanding experiences in context

If meditation is presented primarily as a way to feel calm and comfortable, people may reasonably expect every session to produce those feelings. Unfamiliar experiences may then be confusing, particularly if there is little opportunity to discuss them.

This is one reason the teaching context matters. It can help practitioners understand the purpose of the method, maintain moderation and recognise the support available to them.

I wonder whether separating meditation from its philosophical context and teaching relationship may leave some people less prepared for what they encounter. Whether that separation also contributes to adverse experiences is a question deserving investigation, rather than an explanation we can assume.

Appropriate instruction cannot guarantee freedom from harm. Experienced practitioners can also encounter serious difficulties. Nevertheless, the context in which a practice is understood and offered deserves a place in the discussion.

Taking adverse effects seriously

I appreciate the contribution of researchers such as Willoughby Britton in bringing attention to meditation-related difficulties. Their work challenges the assumption that meditation is universally relaxing, entirely benign or appropriate for everyone in every circumstance.

I would welcome further research distinguishing between techniques, their intensity and duration, the circumstances of practitioners, and the role of instruction and ongoing guidance.

Traditional knowledge and contemporary research both have valuable contributions to make. Understanding meditation’s spiritual purpose should deepen our responsibility towards practitioners and their experiences.

The accounts in the ABC podcasts deserve that care, including when they challenge expectations or explanations familiar within our traditions. Acknowledging harm and responding appropriately are essential to preserving trust in the teaching relationship.

Returning to the purpose of meditation

Josh’s Jarring Things makes a valuable contribution by returning attention to preparation, traditional knowledge and guidance. I would add that the purpose of meditation belongs at the centre of this conversation.

Within Maharishi’s teaching, the experience of Being can become an enduring foundation for life. His descriptions of Cosmic Consciousness and Unity Consciousness express a vision of awareness developing beyond the meditation session into our understanding of ourselves and our relationship with the world.

For me, this connects meditation with meaning, purpose and responsibility. Its value finds expression in how we live, how we relate to others and how we participate in the wider world.

We can investigate adverse effects, respond compassionately to distress and value scientific research while preserving this wider understanding. Measures of stress, sleep and psychological wellbeing contribute to the conversation, but they cannot encompass the whole meaning of meditation within the Vedic tradition.

In making meditation accessible, we should take care to preserve the knowledge, guidance and reverence for the living yogic tradition through which these teachings have reached us.

Meditation is embedded within the philosophical and practical tradition of Yoga. Within the Vedic tradition I teach, its ultimate purpose is to experience Being, deepen our understanding of consciousness and the Self, and bring that awareness into how we live.

For me, meditation is one of the most natural, yet often forgotten, arts of returning to Being—to who we are. It is a much-needed practice today, when we have drifted so far from what it means to be human Beings.

Avril Bastiansz
Yoga & Shakti Mantra Vedic Meditation Teacher
Become You | Shakti Yoga & Meditation School

Listen and read further

ABC’s All in the Mind — When Meditation Goes Wrong

Josh Pryor’s response on Yoga Australia

Next
Next

Avril Interview with Beverley Pinder OAM on Southern FM 24 September, 2026